[摘要]：《红楼梦》是文学历史上的瑰宝，她的迷离色彩，真知灼见，晦隐之语，都悬吊着所有读者的心弦。相比较而言《金粉世家》在文学价值上并未显得如同《红楼梦》一样的宝贵价值，但就在那样的时代的而言，可谓是民国时期的《红楼梦》并不为过。近年来，关于张恨水的研究越来越多，他的作品也被很多学者研究。张恨水的作品大多被拍成影视作品，随着这一阵热潮，《金粉世家》颇受好评。不少学者发现《金粉世家》与《红楼梦》之间相似度颇高，于是有人开始将这两部作品进行比较，每个学者研究的方向不同，大致可分为语言优劣、悲剧意识、人物形象、表现手法等方向。张恨水先生年少时本就是专爱“风流才子高人隐士”的行为，《金粉世家》在这“风流才子高人隐士”的基础上却已摆脱了才子佳人的悲欢离合模式。本文试从两部作品的悲剧主题，人物形象，精神实质三个方面浅显阐述两部作品的异同，从中体现两部作品的精神诉求和作者内心的悲欢离合。

[关键词]  《金粉世家》、《红楼梦》、悲剧主题、人物形象、精神实质

[Abstract]: "A Dream of Red Mansions" is a gem in the literary history of her blurred color, vision, dark hidden language, are suspended chord with all readers. Compared to "Noble" in terms of literary value did not appear as invaluable as the "Dream of Red Mansions", but as the times, can be described as the Republic of the "Dream of Red Mansions" is not an exaggeration . In recent years, more and more and Zhang, his work has also been research by many scholars. And Zhang works are mostly made ​​into a film and television works, acclaimed With a boom, "Noble". Many scholars have found high similarity between the "Noble Family" and "A Dream of Red Mansions", so people began to carry out these two works, each of academic researchers in a different direction, can be divided into the language of the pros and cons, tragic consciousness the direction of the characters, the expression means. "A Dream of Red Mansions" is a step legend, its cultural heritage and spiritual essence of worthy people study a lot of young Mr. Zhang Henshui This is designed to love the Libertine expert hermit "behavior," Noble "" Libertine on the basis of an expert hermit "already out of the mode of the ups and downs of the genius and beauty. This paper tries to work from the two tragic theme, characters, and the spiritual essence of the three aspects of simple to elaborate the similarities and differences of the two works, which reflect the ups and downs of the spiritual aspirations of the two works and of the inner.

[Key words] "Noble", "Dream of Red Mansions", a tragic theme characters, the spiritual essence of